10 Best Ice Fishing Gloves: Reviewed & Compared

Last Updated on

Even though ice fishing is a fantastic pass-time, it’s more or less an outdoor endurance sport. Therefore, you’d need specialized gear to hack it. Talking about gear, ice fishing gloves are a must-have.

Without them, you’d find it extremely difficult to cast or even operate your fish finder. So, let’s guide you through some of the fishing gloves that can help you handle the fishing lines like the pro you are.

Top Ice Fishing Gloves ​Compared

Whether looking for waterproof or water-resistant fishing gloves, the following table will come in handy. A closer look at it will help you make an informed decision even if you don’t have the time for detailed analyses.

Ranking

Image

Product

Size

Weight

Check Price

1

MCTi Waterproof Mens Ski Gloves Winter Warm 3M...

MCTi Waterproof 

-

0.54 ounces

2

Men's Extreme Cold Weather Glove - S - BLACK

Men's Extreme Cold 

-

8.8 ounces

3

Youngstown Glove 03-3450-80-XL Waterproof Winter...

Youngstown Glove 03-3450-80-XL 

5 x 5 inches

5.6 ounces

4

Memphis Glove N9690FCL Ninja Ice FC Nylon Back...

Memphis Glove N9690FCL Ninja

3.3 x 0.1 x 9.3 inches

1.6 ounces

5

POSA Palmyth 2 Cut Fingers Fishing Gloves...

POSA Palmyth

2 Cut Fingers

-

-

6

Rapala Fisherman's Gloves, Large

Rapala Fisherman's Gloves

-

-

7

Black Diamond Mercury Mitts Cold Weather Mittens,...

Black Diamond Mercury Mitts

14 x 5 x 3 inches

11.2 ounces

8

Glacier Glove ICE BAY Fishing Glove, Black, Medium

Glacier Glove ICE BAY Fishing Glove

12.8 x 5.7 x 3.2 inches

0.32 ounces

9

WindRider Rugged Waterproof Winter Gloves |...

Rugged Waterproof Winter Gloves

-

-

10

Pro Angler, Medium

Pro Angler

-

13 ounces

Best Ice Fishing Gloves ​Reviewed

1. MCTi Men’s Waterproof Ski Gloves

On Sale
MCTi Waterproof Mens Ski Gloves Winter Warm 3M...
1,357 Reviews
MCTi Waterproof Mens Ski Gloves Winter Warm 3M...
  • 3M Thinsulate Insulation: The gloves are...
  • Waterproof and Windproof Function: The...
  • Wear Resistance: Soft full covered Nuback...
  • Zipper Pocket and Custom Fit: The pocket is...

To begin with, these are just as waterproof as the name suggests. They are also windproof so your hands will remain warm in windy and rainy conditions.

These gloves are thick and will ensure that your hands remain warm during winter. They come with two wraps on the wrist which you can tie just to be sure that it is properly fit and will not come off easily. They also fit well to retain the warmth in your hands.

The fingers are reinforced with rubber and this ensures that the grip is fairly strong and that they are resistant to wear and tear. The package comes with a small pocket which you can use to carry ID cards and keys. The interior has an extremely soft lining meaning you can comfortably wear them for long periods of time.

Pros
  • It fits well
  • Water and windproof
  • Durable
Cons
  • They are thick and may give you a hard time controlling levers

2. Skinz Seal Extreme Cold Weather Glove

On Sale
Men's Extreme Cold Weather Glove - S - BLACK
1 Reviews
Men's Extreme Cold Weather Glove - S - BLACK
  • Totally waterproof, breathable and windproof
  • All over insulation & full length gaiter...
  • Pre-curved fingers & knuckle feature designed...

These gloves will keep your hands completely dry during your outdoor venture. It has a comfy wrist strap which will further reinforce this waterproof and snow-proof feature.

The fingers are pre-curved such that even if you have extremely wet and cold fingers, sliding them into and out of the gloves will not be a problem. It has a leather palm which apart from enhancing the grip ensures that your hands are really comfortable with them on while you partake in other ventures.

Apart from the main glove, it has an inner glove which means that they will keep your hands very warm even in the lowest temperatures out there.

Pros
  • It has a nice grip
  • It is breathable
  • The wrist strap reinforces its good fit on the hands
Cons
  • Water tends to penetrate through the strap
  • It is not completely windproof

3. Youngstown Waterproof 03-3450-80-XL Glove

On Sale
Youngstown Glove 03-3450-80-XL Waterproof Winter...
1,102 Reviews
Youngstown Glove 03-3450-80-XL Waterproof Winter...
  • An all-purpose winter work glove designed to...
  • Features 40g 3M Thinsulate, soft micro-fleece...
  • The form-fit outer glove features non-slip...
  • Warmth varies from person to person. This is...

These gloves are perfect for freezing conditions. It is made from a combination of materials such as polyester, Nylon, and cotton which will ensure that your hands will remain completely dry. Additionally, all these layers will ensure that your hands remain warm even in freezing conditions.

The outer shell is firm and is reinforced with tough material which will ensure that the grip is strong and eliminates chances of slip-ups. The design of the gloves allows your hand to fit perfectly in them and so you will be guaranteed maximum comfort while they are on.

They are breathable and so the case of sweaty hands will not be there. Finally, they have a Velcro closure at the base to prevent entry o wind and air.

Pros
  • It fits perfectly
  • It is water and windproof
  • They are thick for the purpose of warmth
Cons
  • They are extremely small

4. Memphis N9690FCL Ninja Ice Glove

Memphis Glove N9690FCL Ninja Ice FC Nylon Back...
62 Reviews
Memphis Glove N9690FCL Ninja Ice FC Nylon Back...
  • Gloves/Cold Weather Gloves
  • Memphis Glove Large Black Ninja ICE FC 7...
  • Made in: United States
  • Ninja Ice FC double layer glove

The outer shell of this model is made of nylon and this helps in repelling the liquids away. It is also quite flexible as you continue using it. It has a double layer of skin which contributes to keeping your hands warm.

The grip is perfect and the coating is quite soft so that your hands remain as comfortable as possible during use. Taking them off and putting back on is not hard at all.

It is breathable and so your hands will not be sweaty however long you put the gloves on. If you are a fan of black colored items, then this is for you.

Pros
  • It has a good grip
  • It is breathable
  • It has a nice fit
Cons
  • They are not completely waterproof

5. POSA 2 Cut Fingers Palmyth Fishing Gloves

POSA Palmyth 2 Cut Fingers Fishing Gloves...
41 Reviews
POSA Palmyth 2 Cut Fingers Fishing Gloves...
  • Unique Design: You can take off the thumb and...
  • Comfortable Fabric: The front fabric of...
  • Excellent Performance: Soft material allow...
  • Adjustable Gloves: Built-in invisible elastic...

If you want to stand out from your peers, then this model is just for you. First, the forefinger and the thumb glove cover are removable. So if there is a task that requires direct contact with your fingers such as unlocking your phone or fingerprint sensors, you will not need to remove the entire gloves.

They are comfortable and fit well meaning that you can wear them for hours without feeling like you are under stress or something. The back of the gloves is tough and would protect your hands in case you come into contact with a rough surface which could potentially hurt you.

It is flexible and the coating ensures that the grip is as strong as it may get. Finally, it has a Velcro wrist strap which would reinforce how good it fits in your hands.

Pros
  • They fit perfectly
  • The grip is awesome
  • It has removable fingertips and so will not damage your phone
Cons
  • They do not keep your hands warm

6. Rapala Fisherman Marine Glove

Rapala Fisherman's Gloves, Large
360 Reviews
Rapala Fisherman's Gloves, Large
  • Non-slip fish handling gloves.
  • Fresh or Saltwater
  • designed to float
  • Durable Latex Coating.

The first impressive detail with these gloves is the excellent grip that they have. On top of that, they will safeguard your hands from scratches and cuts which may come along as you are on your boat.

They have a latex layer which makes them really durable over the years. They are also quite easy to clean and dry fast. Even better is that washing them does not disrupt the shape or design.

Pros
  • They are durable
  • Easy to wash
  • They have excellent grip
Cons
  • They are not waterproof

7. Black Mercury Diamond Cold Weather Mittens

On Sale
Black Diamond Mercury Mitts Cold Weather Mittens,...
145 Reviews
Black Diamond Mercury Mitts Cold Weather Mittens,...
  • 100% waterproof Dry insert stays with...
  • Lightweight, abrasion-resistant, Pretext...
  • Removable liner is insulated with combination...

This pair gives you a unique and classy look. They are thick enough to keep your hands really warm without interfering in any task that you may be required to undertake as you ski.

It is water-resistant and so your hands will remain dry throughout your ventures. The leather palm has a removable inner layer which has which has a waterproof fabric outer shell which will further enable your hands to remain dry.

The outer shell is tough and durable so you can rest assured that it will serve you for years to come. It has a wrist strap with a Velcro ring which will aid in locking it in place. This strap will also help in maintaining the heat as well keeping out the snow.

It is washable and has a loop which you can use to hang it upside down to let it dry. Additionally, the back of the thumb has a softer fabric which can come in handy if you ever need to wipe your nose or clean your goggles.

Pros
  • They are warm
  • They are durable
  • There is a loop to facilitate dryingThere is a loop to facilitate drying
Cons
  • It has a poor dexterity

8. Glacier Ice Bay Fishing Glove

On Sale
Glacier Glove ICE BAY Fishing Glove, Black, Medium
512 Reviews
Glacier Glove ICE BAY Fishing Glove, Black, Medium
  • 100% Waterproof
  • 2MM Fleece Lined Neoprene
  • Seamless Palm Design
  • Blind Stiched & Glued

If you want gloves that may outlive you, then here lies the solution. They are made from neoprene material which enhances this durability feature. This material will also help in keeping your hands dry and warm since it is water and windproof.

This model has enough room to accommodate any movement for your fingers. This means that you can even comfortably operate your phone while the gloves are still on. The fabric is tight fitting to ensure that it is 100% waterproof.

It fits nicely and this is compounded by the wrist strap that comes with it. Last but not least it has a textured pattern which means that the grip is always awesome.

Pros
  • They are durable
  • They have a good grip
  • They keep your hands completely warm and dry
Cons
  • They are not breathable

9. Rugged Cordura Shell Winter Waterproof Gloves

WindRider Rugged Waterproof Winter Gloves |...
217 Reviews
WindRider Rugged Waterproof Winter Gloves |...
  • TOUCHSCREEN FINGER TIPS allow you to answer...
  • WATERPROOF - We are talking stick your hand...
  • RUGGED CONSTRUCTION - First we take a Cordura...
  • STORAGE - You can't ever have enough pockets,...

This model is both stylish and unique. The first feature that sticks out when you set your eyes on it is the “Touchscreen Finger Tips”. This means that you can comfortably answer your phone calls with the gloves still on. Note that this is limited to answering phone calls.

They are also waterproof. This implies that however much water that you will encounter out there will not be enough to penetrate the gloves. So feel free to stick your hands in the river or lake to pick out something without worrying about your hands getting wet.

The pair has a rugged exterior which makes them durable and grippy. The inner layer is soft and leaves a good feeling for your hands. They will always be comfortable no matter how long you wear them.

Lastly, they have pockets for holding your keys, ID and credit cards.

Pros
  • They are durable
  • They are waterproof
  • They maintain the heat
Cons
  • They are too big

Catch More Fish With These Articles Below

Best Ice Fishing Rods  - Top 10 Review

The Best Ice Fishing Fish Finders Compared

10. Pro Angler Gloves

Pro Angler, Medium
95 Reviews
Pro Angler, Medium
  • Slit Finger on Thumb and Pointer Finger
  • 2MM Fleece Lined Neoprene
  • Techline Neoprene. 100% waterproof
  • Pre-Curved Fingers

The outstanding feature of these gloves is the slits which allow you to take out your fingertips whenever needed. This includes operating your phone or unhooking a fish. The pre-curved fingers will ensure that your fingers fit in the gloves perfectly and are also quite comfortable.

The gloves are made out of Neoprene which makes it very waterproof. It is also tough and so you can be sure that these gloves will last for a long time to come.

At the wrist, there is a hook-and-loop cuff strap which ensures that the gloves are as tight as possible on your hands. You will never have to worry about the gloves coming off without your approval.    

Pros
  • They are waterproof
  • The fit perfectly
  • They are durableThey are durable
Cons
  • They are a bit too pricey

Cold Weather Glove Buying Guide

Choosing the ideal pair of gloves in a sea full of options might sound like a herculean task. Fortunately, you don’t have to be confused. These are some of the factors to always pay attention to, in your quest for the best quality.

The Kind of Material Used

The debate on waterproof vs. water-resistant ice fishing gloves has been raging for quite some time now. But to bring clarity, we’d like to state a few things. Both types of gloves come with their fair share of merits and demerits.

Water resistant gloves, for instance, may be prone to punctures and tears. Water-proof gloves, on the other hand, may prove difficult to maintain owing to their many seams.

The good news is that both varieties can work for ice fishing. So, the only question you need to ask yourself is whether your glove of choice is properly insulated or not. That brings us to the next point – warmth.

Warmth

Don’t just look for comfortable fishing gloves. It’s even more important to remember that winters can get overwhelmingly cold. Our basic recommendation is that you should not settle for anything with less than 40 grams of thinsulate material.

Comfort

Comfort is important especially since fishing requires your hands to move freely. That said, you should avoid gloves that are fully made from rubber. Our expert reviewers recommend nylon and nylon gloves made with 40 grams of Thinsulate or more.

Should I Buy Gloves Or Mittens?

This is yet another tricky choice you’re bound to face. Our best suggestion is that you should only go for mittens if you’re planning to do basic ice duties e.g. snowmobile. However, if you’re looking to get the most out of your fishing trip, we’d recommend sticking with gloves.


Which One Is The Best?

All of the gloves reviewed are made with quality. The Youngstown Waterproof 03-3450-80-XL Glove stands out for very cold conditions with its unique design. It’s made from a complex blend of material all adding up to a work glove with an amazing design. The pair also meets the 40g Thinsulate threshold which means they’re warm as well.


Final Thoughts

No matter your style of fishing, it’s always important to be ready for everything the ice wilderness may throw at you. One way to be fully prepared is by getting the best ice fishing gloves. That decision may set you back a few dollars – a small price to pay for warm hands and better casting abilities.